Reviews
Guidelines for writing a review
A) sensible to understand regarding review articles
B) components of a review
C) pointers for making ready a review in eighteen steps
D) samples of high-quality review articles within the plant sciences (to be employed in
your own work)
E) References employed in this Guideline
A) sensible to understand regarding review articles
What is a review article?
• A crucial, constructive analysis of the literature in a specific field through the outline,
classification, analysis, comparison.
• A scientific text wishing on antecedently printed literature or information. New information from the
author’s experiments don't seem to be bestowed (with exceptions: some reviews contain new
data).
• A complete publication. Literature reviews as integral elements of master theses, doctoral
theses or grant proposals won't be thought-about here. However, several tips during this
guideline square measure transferable to those text varieties.
What is the performing of a review article?
• to prepare literature
• to judge literature
• to spot patterns and trends within the literature
• to synthesize literature
• to spot analysis gaps and advocate new analysis areas
Who is that the audience of review articles?
• consultants in specific analysis areas
• students or novice researchers
• decision-makers
Review articles targeted at the last 2 groups: Extended explanations of subjects or of
subject-specific language square measure necessary (e.g. through the uses of knowledge boxes or
glossaries).
Which styles of review articles exist?
Types by method approach
• Narrative review
Selected studies square measure compared and summarized on the idea of the author’s expertise,
existing theories, and models. Results square measure supported a qualitative instead of a
quantitative level.
• Best proof review
A focus on hand-picked studies is combined with systematic ways of study-selection and
result exploration.
• Systematic review
Findings from numerous individual studies square measure analyzed statistically by strict procedures.
Meta-Analyses square measure wont to pool the results of individual studies.
A) sensible to understand regarding review articles
B) components of a review
C) pointers for making ready a review in eighteen steps
D) samples of high-quality review articles within the plant sciences (to be employed in
your own work)
E) References employed in this Guideline
A) sensible to understand regarding review articles
What is a review article?
• A crucial, constructive analysis of the literature in a specific field through the outline,
classification, analysis, comparison.
• A scientific text wishing on antecedently printed literature or information. New information from the
author’s experiments don't seem to be bestowed (with exceptions: some reviews contain new
data).
• A complete publication. Literature reviews as integral elements of master theses, doctoral
theses or grant proposals won't be thought-about here. However, several tips during this
guideline square measure transferable to those text varieties.
What is the performing of a review article?
• to prepare literature
• to judge literature
• to spot patterns and trends within the literature
• to synthesize literature
• to spot analysis gaps and advocate new analysis areas
Who is that the audience of review articles?
• consultants in specific analysis areas
• students or novice researchers
• decision-makers
Review articles targeted at the last 2 groups: Extended explanations of subjects or of
subject-specific language square measure necessary (e.g. through the uses of knowledge boxes or
glossaries).
Which styles of review articles exist?
Types by method approach
• Narrative review
Selected studies square measure compared and summarized on the idea of the author’s expertise,
existing theories, and models. Results square measure supported a qualitative instead of a
quantitative level.
• Best proof review
A focus on hand-picked studies is combined with systematic ways of study-selection and
result exploration.
• Systematic review
Findings from numerous individual studies square measure analyzed statistically by strict procedures.
Meta-Analyses square measure wont to pool the results of individual studies.
No comments